Polishing crankset

[FastforaSlowGuy]

I've got a used Shimano XTR crankset heading my way and want to shine it up before installing on my wife's bike. Any suggestions for the right way to polish it up without discoloring or scratching the aluminum?

[ColonelJLloyd]

Which model XTR crankset? I'm assuming it's anodized. You'll have to remove the anodized coating before beginning the polishing process. I've done this several times by stripping, wet sanding with 400, 600 and 1,000 grit sandpaper, followed by a buffing wheel and compound or Blue Magic and a cloth.

This is what I use to remove the anodizing.

I stripped and polished a Truvativ Elita this week actually.


Untitled by ColonelJLloyd, on Flickr


Untitled by ColonelJLloyd, on Flickr


Untitled by ColonelJLloyd, on Flickr


Untitled by ColonelJLloyd, on Flickr

[Lewis Moon]

The good colonel is correct if you need to create a mirror finish. I use 100 grit and elbow grease to remove anodizing. It's also nice to touch up any mold marks that may have been missed at the factory. If you just want to do a surface polish w/o stripping the anodizing, I use chrome polish and soft rag. That will take off the factory graphics and spiff up the surface....just be careful not to polish in one place too long. Better done by hand. I just did this to a set of Centaur cranks.
Incedentally, I used the same polish to smooth out some rub marks that came on a set of used chorus carbon cranks. Worked very well.

[AngryScientist]

i agree with the approach above

some 105 cranks i did:

[Shoeman]

I've heard oven cleaner works on the removal of the clear ano. Then wet sanding down to 1500 or 2000 grit follow with buffing wheel and rouge from Harbor Freight.

[ColonelJLloyd]

Oven cleaner (lye) does work, and I have used it with success, but the anodizing remover I linked above has more predictable results and is easier to work with.

[FastforaSlowGuy]

May be a stupid question, but any way to do this without stripping the graphics? I ask because I don't yet know whether she'll want them on there or not.

[gone]

Originally Posted by FastforaSlowGuy

May be a stupid question, but any way to do this without stripping the graphics? I ask because I don't yet know whether she'll want them on there or not.

In my experience, no. I've tried various methods of masking off graphics and they always get stripped off during the polishing process no matter how careful I am.

[josephr]

I recently did this same project to a set of Shimano cranks using Mother's Metal Polish and a roll of paper towels. The crank had some smaller barnacles that took a lot of rubbing to remove. I haven't tried a buffing wheel attached to a drill or a bench grinder, but that might help to expedite the process --- just be careful not to remove too much metal.

Yes. It will remove the graphics/lettering and will also strip off the anodizing. Also, to keep it clean, you may want to put a sealer on it like Pedro's bike polish to help keep sweat/grease from oxidizing the aluminum and giving the mirror finish you worked so hard to get from becoming hazy.

Ride hard!
Joe

[chromopromo]

To remove the anodized finish Easy Off oven cleaner works. Just spray on and let sit awhile and wipe off. Then you can start sanding.

[FastforaSlowGuy]

Not sure I want to remove the anno, so I think I will start with just polish.

[Columbus SLX]

Originally Posted by FastforaSlowGuy

Not sure I want to remove the anno, so I think I will start with just polish.

FYI, polishing won't do a thing unless you remove the anodizing. When I want to save the graphics, I mask them with 3M clear packaging tape and an x-acto knife before the Easy-off ano stripping. Obviously, this only works on big "lump" graphics like a Campy shield, not individual letters:

[ColonelJLloyd]

Originally Posted by Columbus SLX

FYI, polishing won't do a thing unless you remove the anodizing.

+1 That's pretty much the point of anodizing.

[josephr]

Originally Posted by Columbus SLX

FYI, polishing won't do a thing unless you remove the anodizing. When I want to save the graphics, I mask them with 3M clear packaging tape and an x-acto knife before the Easy-off ano stripping. Obviously, this only works on big "lump" graphics like a Campy shield, not individual letters:

Maybe I've had too much coffee, but in the reflection it looks like the guy taking the picture is also holding a bloody knife standing over a woman's naked body....

[dfischer1]

Reviving an older thread --has anyone polished the grey off an Ultegra 6800 crankset?

Thanks