PDA

View Full Version : OT: Thousands of villagers struggling in Alaska


William
02-09-2009, 11:33 AM
http://www.cnn.com/2009/US/02/09/rural.alaska.villages/index.html

(CNN) -- Thousands of villagers in rural Alaska are struggling to survive, forced to choose between keeping their families warm and keeping their stomachs full, residents say.

Harvested nuts and berries, small game animals, and dried fish are the only things keeping some from starving.
To get to the nearest store, Ann Strongheart and her husband, who live in Nunam Iqua, Alaska, take an hour-and-15-minute snowmobile ride to Emmonak, Alaska. Their town does not have a store of its own.
Normally, they would each ride a snowmobile, in case one broke down. But now, they can't afford to waste the fuel, so they just take one and hope for the best.
At the store, the Stronghearts buy groceries and supplies for the family for the week, which cost more than $400. They buy only as much as their snowmobile can carry.
In many stores, 2 pounds of cheese costs between $15 and $18, milk costs $10 a gallon, a 5-pound bag of apples costs $15, and a dozen eggs costs $22 -- more than double the price in the area just two years ago.
Many area residents don't even bother with fruits and vegetables, which can be damaged by freezing on the trip home.
After shopping, the Stronghearts pack their groceries into boxes, tie them to the snowmobile, and begin the 25-mile trek home, passing moose, rabbit and fox tracks along the way. The trip sets them back about $50 in fuel alone.
On top of high food prices, some residents are paying nearly $1,500 a month to heat their homes. The Stronghearts live in one of a group of Native American communities along the Yukon-Kuskokwim Delta.
They and other residents of these villages of 200 to 800 residents are feeling the impact of a devastating perfect storm of events. Commercial fishermen couldn't make money from the seasonal king salmon harvest this year, because there was barely enough fish for subsistence. In fact, most fishermen lost money. Then a brutal early winter brought the longest cold snap in five years. In September the temperature in many villages dropped as low as -20 degrees, a record low for many, according to the Alaska Center for Climate Assessment and Policy. The 1,200-mile Yukon River, which the villages use as a highway, froze completely in September, at least two months earlier than usual. That left residents cut off from some basic necessities, and forced them to have pricey bulk fuel flown in.

These residents and their ancestors have lived for hundreds of years in the Yukon Delta, which Emmonak resident Cindy Beans describes as something out of National Geographic. Though they send their kids to school, many speak the native Yup'ik language, and live a much simpler life than even urban Alaskans. They have always had the comfort of food around them -- whatever they can pick, catch and hunt. "But in order to have access to all the subsistence food, you have to be able to get out there and hunt for it," Beans said. And that requires them to go out on their snowmobiles, which means using more fuel. The community is always gathering food, Beans said.

"All summer long we are putting away fish for the winter, by fall working on moose, then setting nets under the ice for winter time. But now, this food which used to supplement groceries is all that people have, since they can't afford to buy food at these prices."
So residents have been forced to rely more on these subsistence methods.
Beans said her brother walks three miles in 20-below-zero weather to check on nets under the ice for fish. The fish is a staple they need to keep themselves fed. "The life out here has always been hard, it's just that its a lot harder now," she said.

Emmonak resident Nicholas Tucker wondered if others were feeling the impact, so he broadcast an inquiry via VHF radio, one of the common ways to communicate in the village. Tucker said many residents sobbed as they radioed him back. "His family has been out of food for quite some time now," Tucker wrote about one resident in a letter sent to legislators and the media. "Their 1-year-old child is out of milk, [he] can't get it and he has no idea when he will be able to get the next can." "There are days without food in his house," Tucker wrote. A single father with five children choked back tears as he told Tucker of his struggle to help his kids. "Right now, we can't eat during the day, only at supper time," Tucker wrote of the man. "If there had been no school lunch our kids would be starving."

Many of the tribal leaders said they are begging the state and federal governments to do something to help. George Lamont, tribal administrator in Tuluksak, Alaska, said because of the crisis and villagers' inability to pay their utility bills, he fears many may have their electricity shut off.

Alaska has given many residents $1,200 energy rebate checks, but residents say it barely helps them with one month's heating costs. Aid agencies, including the Red Cross, aren't an option right now -- the Alaska Red Cross said they couldn't help unless a disaster is declared. But the state hasn't declared an emergency yet, and it can't because of a state statute that requires the average income levels in the villages to drop below $26,500 -- regardless of the cost of living. Alaska Gov. Sarah Palin's office said the state is trying to find a way to free up government help.

"Local government specialists in the state Department of Commerce, Community and Economic Development continue to crunch numbers and seek creative approaches to finding a statutorily acceptable way to justify a disaster declaration, which would open the door to federal aid, as well," deputy press secretary Sharon Leighow said.
Leighow said Palin is sending her new rural advisor, John Moller, to the area next week, accompanied by representatives of the Alaska Food Bank.
Sen. Lisa Murkowski, R-Alaska, asked the Bureau of Indian Affairs to step in and help the towns most in need.
"I find it ironic, tragically ironic, that it takes an economic downturn in the rest of the country for this Congress to consider an economic stimulus for Indian Country," she said during a Senate Committee on Indian Affairs economic stimulus hearing. The villagers hold out hope that the state or federal governments can come through. "People have really been looking forward to some emergency assistance," Lamont said.

After hearing the stories from his neighbors, Tucker said it's clear help is needed now. "We have remained quiet, cried and suffered in silence," he said.
"So now, this is our simple cry to others for help."

JeffS
02-09-2009, 01:52 PM
And somehow those ancestors managed without having to ride a snowmobile to a store...

Sorry, but I'm not shedding any tears over the cost of distributing eggs and milk to rural Alaska.

fiamme red
02-09-2009, 01:57 PM
http://www.themudflats.net/2009/01/25/shopping-day-in-nunam-iqua-alaska/

Pete Serotta
02-09-2009, 02:23 PM
folks in the lower 48 have many of the same problems....

Unforunately many are suffering in the USA - and quite a few of them are just victims of the financial environment (jobs)

Ray
02-09-2009, 02:32 PM
And somehow those ancestors managed without having to ride a snowmobile to a store...

If you should ever hit the skids for whatever reason, do you want us to hold you to the same standard? If your ancestors could handle living without electricity, plumbing, medical care, or any freedoms, you should be able to do the same?

Just saying man - that's a pretty tough standard for any inhabitant of the modern world.

-Ray

Kirk007
02-09-2009, 02:38 PM
ditto - I don't know what else to say. Empathy, compassion - there but for the grace of [insert your favorite force] go many of us.

Ozz
02-09-2009, 02:57 PM
...Just saying man - that's a pretty tough standard for any inhabitant of the modern world.

-Ray
True, but when I read it, I was reminded of the Sam Kinison routine about world hunger...."don't send food.....send U-Hauls and luggage so they can move to where the food is!"

Alaska is a tough place to live.....and all life exists on a razors edge.

Michael Maddox
02-09-2009, 02:57 PM
True, but when I read it, I was reminded of the Sam Kinison routine about world hunger...."don't send food.....send U-Hauls and luggage so they can move to where the food is!"

Alaska is a tough place to live.....and all life exists on a razors edge.

I thought the same thing, "Why don't they move?"

Of course, it takes money to move, too, and it's not necessarily a feasible alternative in the midst of an Alaskan winter, either.

johnnymossville
02-09-2009, 03:08 PM
This is all Sarah Palin's fault. If she had any compassion she'd send some dead wolves or something.

Ozz
02-09-2009, 03:10 PM
...Of course, it takes money to move, too, and it's not necessarily a feasible alternative in the midst of an Alaskan winter, either.
True, but it is not as if life being hard there is a secret or just happened.

About 30+ years ago, the spotted owl became the icon for saving old-growth forests and effectively putting an end to large scale logging employment in the PNW. Many communites all over Washington were decimated....

Every year since then, there are several stories are written or broadcast about how tough things are in those communities.....I don't get it. The writing was on the wall 30 years ago, and the doing the folks complaining were about 5 when the end was in sight. But they wanted the same job their fathers and grandfathers had and didn't plan their future very well.

Again, I don't get it....

csm
02-09-2009, 03:19 PM
maybe the vilf could shoot a moose or two to help.
I guess she is not a vcilf.

Ray
02-09-2009, 03:21 PM
Whether those kinds of communities are sustainable in modern society is a legit question for debate. Whether those folks should ultimately relocate is a legit question. Whether Sarah Palin is to blame isn't - she's ALWAYS to blame. :cool:

But saying that you don't feel any sympathy for people because of how their frickin' ANCESTORS lived? Gimme a break. Could any of us meet that standard? Damn, my ancestors ate only the food they killed or grew, got around only on their own two feet (maybe the richest among 'em had a horse), generally died when they got sick, probably got guillotined for looking at the wrong person funny. They obviously didn't have plumbing or electricity or, OH MY GOD, cell phones! I'd be dead in a week. Most of you would be too.

Darwin is one thing, but DAMN!

-Ray

Kirk007
02-09-2009, 03:31 PM
Again, I don't get it....


I agree with much, most of this sentiment, particularly living here in the Pac. NW. Factories close, minerals are mined out and companies move on; it is a common phenomena, particularly here in the West when we talk about natural resource extraction, at least for us whose history on this land started in the last couple hundred years.

But, I think it is a bit more complex though when talking about tribes/first nations and a (partially) subsistence way of life. Picking up and moving may well be the equivalent of abandoning not just a job or place, but a culture, an identity that is tied to the landscape. I'm sure for many it is the very last of choices, just as it has been for many in the past, here and elsewhere who have left homelands behind for myriad reasons when life became impossible. (I'm sure my ancestors left Ireland for Ellis Island for reasons other than they wanted a bon voyage). And it will continue for economic, social and environmental reasons.

Kirk007
02-09-2009, 03:41 PM
This is all Sarah Palin's fault. If she had any compassion she'd send some dead wolves or something.

nothing funny about her wolf kill program or her lack of understanding or appreciation of modern conservation biology. It does seem though, that a "compassionate" governor would be raising awareness of this issue and pressing for a response, more than we've seen to date. Clearly this didn't develop overnight.

RPS
02-09-2009, 03:45 PM
Darwin is one thing, but DAMN!

-RayTough crowd?
What would you do for them?

I see them ahead of the curve, just needing global warming to arrive sooner. ;)

SamIAm
02-09-2009, 04:04 PM
Clearly this didn't develop overnight.

You are right, they have had decades to move.

SamIAm
02-09-2009, 04:05 PM
Tough crowd?
What would you do for them?

;)

Ray would be happy to give them your money.

gdw
02-09-2009, 04:19 PM
Let's sell it back to the Russians since the environmentalists won't allow us to tap the oil reserves or blast the furry critters. We only paid $7.2 million for it so the profit margin should be pretty sweet.

Ray
02-09-2009, 04:19 PM
Tough crowd?
What would you do for them?

Dunno - haven't thought about this particular population until an hour ago or so. I might be a heartless enough bastid to force them to relocate. I might spend some of Sam's money to help them with that :cool:.

None of that was my point - it was the damn "do as your ancestors did" comment that struck me as particularly over the top. That's all.

Global warming. Heh heh.

-Ray

Kirk007
02-09-2009, 04:30 PM
come on now Ray, its climate change not global warming, so get with the program if you're going to stick with us pack of bleeding heart liberal environment loving, socialist leaning dreamers ; )

GW doesn't work for us any more as these damn short term patterns keep on getting in the claw of everyone who wants consistency with the term warming. Either that or focus on the land down under, where drought, fire and floods are unleashing a torrent of suffering, misery and loss of homes and life.

fourflys
02-09-2009, 04:41 PM
OK, I have to post on this one...

I lived on Kodiak Island for 3 years a few years ago and while Kodiak may not be as desolate as this town sounds, this story sounds a little exagerated. For one thing, the family name mentioned sounds like an Alaska native name and I can tell first hand the natives get some of the best healthcare and social programs support than anyone else in Alaska or the lower 48. And as far as having to take a snowmobile to the store... I know of at least two chains that do "bush shipping" to the small villages....

No doubt times are tough and may well be tougher in small village Alaska, but they also get the Alaska permanent fund dividend. In 2008, the amount was $3269 PER FAMILY MEMBER, so a family of four made $13k last year! Sorry, I'm not feeling too bad for them...
Alaska PFD (https://www.pfd.state.ak.us/)

Chris

Kirk007
02-09-2009, 04:46 PM
You are right, they have had decades to move.

Oye, yes they have - same can be said for a lot of folks whose land may be underwater or uninhabitable in the next decade or so, here and elsewhere. Or whose local economies have been failing, yet they hang on to the lives they know and the lands they love despite the bleak economic fortunes that face them. Indeed, the flight from rural agrarian economies to cities has been happening for a long time, which has caused it's own issues, both in cities and in the heartland. So, where do all of these fine folks move to and what will they do? For those outside of the US, the good ole USA surely looks mighty tempting to many, as it has for a long long time. Which then gets us to immigration, our economy etc.

These are just additional difficult issues that we have to grapple with, in an already difficult time. It is easy to say from an intellectual point of view, as I myself have done with respect to loggers on the Olympic peninsula, "pick up and move, get retrained, move on for god's sake." Much more difficult I suspect when you are the one who is being told to pack. And even if that is the correct solution, it doesn't change the fact that American citizens are starving today (and as Pete points out its not just in Alaska).

Seems like a lot of dark clouds on the horizon to me.

93legendti
02-09-2009, 04:50 PM
It's not "her" wolf control progran. It is Alaska's and it predates Gov. Palin:

http://www.cnn.com/EARTH/9711/19/wolves.reut/

Large wolf population threatens caribou

Without any action to reduce wolf predation, the Fortymile caribou herd may not rebound from its depressed state, said Frank Rue, commissioner of the Alaska Department of Fish and Game Rue.

The herd's troubles can be traced to the 1950s and 1960s, when the animals were overhunted by humans, he said.

An 18-member team, with hunters and representatives of native, environmental and tourism groups, came up with the Fortymile wolf plan. The team included representatives from the Yukon Territory's government and a native tribe there.

Alaska is the only U.S. state where wolves are not endangered or threatened.


http://seattletimes.nwsource.com/cgi-bin/PrintStory.pl?document_id=2003696245&zsection_id=2003925728&slug=webwolves06&date=20070506

Alaska falls short of kills in wolf control program
By The Associated Press

ANCHORAGE, Alaska – The state is far from meeting its goal in its aerial wolf-kill program that ended April 30.

In the effort, 175 wolves were reported killed, a fraction of up to 664 animals targeted by wildlife managers. Total numbers could rise because trappers and hunters have until May 30 to report kills, but officials don't expect a big increase.

Thin snow in many areas made tracking wolves difficult and high fuel prices kept some pilots and aerial gunners grounded.

"It's a big deal," said Cliff Judkins, chairman of the Alaska Board of Game. "We ought to increase the (killing) methods to meet our goals, and we keep playing around when we need to get the job done."

But advocacy group Defenders of Wildlife contends the low numbers are due to a lack of wolves. Conservation groups say the state has overestimated wolf numbers and so many have been killed in past years that they're more difficult to find.

The game board launched the predator-control effort five years ago to boost moose populations. The program is run in five areas of the state. This winter, the goal was met in one area.

The program accounts for a fraction of the total annual kill of about 1,000 wolves in state. Alaska trappers take most of the animals for the hides.

Conservation groups and others have protested against the predator-control program because state-issued permits allow private gunners to shoot wolves from planes.

To accelerate the number of kills this year, the state Department of Fish and Game decided to offer a $150 bounty for the left front leg of every dead wolf. Advocacy groups sued and a state Superior Court judge ordered the bounty stopped before a payment had been made, saying the department lacked the authority to offer a bounty.

Wolf attacks on pets and humans:

http://wolfcrossing.org/2007/12/23/links-to-all-alaska-wolf-stories/

johnnymossville
02-09-2009, 04:57 PM
I wish they would allow shooting deer from helicopters here in Maryland. The things are lying dead along roads EVERYWHERE!

Kirk007
02-09-2009, 05:00 PM
Yeah Adam,

I did a critique of the program for my degree back in 1980. It didn't make biological sense then and it doesn't now. Nothing in Alaska fish and game thought has changed. And the "threat" to the caribou herd - I'm not buying it; its the same song and dance that we've heard for 50-60 years - managing ungulates for hunters; killing off apex predators like wolves that "compete" with man. Good maybe for hunters; sucks for greater ecosystem protection and resilience, and the species that inhabit those ecosystems (not to mention the wolves who are run to exhaustion by airplanes and helicopters before being gunned down (lucky for the species they are very resilient). Read some of the literature re changes to Yellowstone ecosystem since wolves were reintroduced to see what I mean about ecosystem health and the documented changes in the past ten-fifteen years. For us biologists at least, its pretty interesting stuff.

BTW, I thought the Gov was the Fish and Game guy's boss? Doesn' t that make it her program now? Or does the buck no longer stop at the big guy/girl's desk?

Kirk007
02-09-2009, 05:25 PM
I wish they would allow shooting deer from helicopters here in Maryland. The things are lying dead along roads EVERYWHERE!

Could be dangerous for car drivers though!

Yes the explosion of deer populations (and many other species) is a huge problem for natural systems, for agriculture, for human safety - lots of folks die each year from auto collisions with deer. Turkeys, coyotes, many species are exploding in population. Some states can barely issue enough hunting licenses to keep up. Our systems are badly out of sync as the natural checks and balances that once existed have been removed by man and our management has not adequately addressed it. I could have turkey or deer every night of the week if I had the appropriate cart, permission and weapon on almost every ride I do out here in Oregon.

93legendti
02-09-2009, 05:48 PM
I wish they would allow shooting deer from helicopters here in Maryland. The things are lying dead along roads EVERYWHERE!
Save the wolves!

Amazing that the story involves a winter that is too cold. I thought the ice was melting in Alaska and causing problems. Now, I find out the problem is it is too cold. I wish the climate would make up its mind.