Recs for a decent Dynamo Hub

[kohlboto]

My incoming DeSalvo will have provisions to run a Dynamo hub but I'm a bit clueless of where to start looking for a hub. My only criteria is I'd like the best balance between function and price...and I'm looking for a 28 hole hub since I have a spare 28 hole A23 kicking around. Any suggestions where to start or who to contact would be thoroughly appreciated.
cheers
Jay

[R2D2]

Read up on Peter White's site. The Schmidt is top shelf. Sanyo and Shimano make some great cheaper alternatives.

[fiamme red]

Here's an overview of the Schmidt hubs: http://janheine.wordpress.com/2012/12/13/overview-of-son-generator-hubs/

[bargainguy]

I have the Shimano dynamo on my Brompton and love it. Alas, I don't think they make a 28, only 32 & 36.

Brompton also offers the SON dynamo, which is awesome but mucho deniero, at least twice the price of the Shimano if not more.

[pbbob]

I have a shutter precision [sp dynamo] laced to to a 28hole rim if I remember correctly.
works great.

[NHAero]

I have the Schmidt which works perfectly. Recent;y bought an SP off of eBay and am going to get it built up, to try the less expensive approach on another bike

[kohlboto]

Just a quick update...
I'm going with the Shutter Precision hub and, based on a V-salon thread, I purchased it packaged with a light through Kerry at: http://www.klite.com.au/
The package price seems really good and I was very impressed with his help and patience in answering all my questions. The hub will be on its way to Echelon John for a build so I will relay some real world impressions in the near future...
Thanks for everyone's input and suggestions.

[559Rando]

Read up on Peter White's site. The Schmidt is top shelf. Sanyo and Shimano make some great cheaper alternatives.

+1

If you want "decent" then the $50 Sanyo is hard to beat. The better Shimanos can be found around $125. The Schmidt (SON) stuff is close to $300.

Better prices can usually be found on dynamo lighting and hubs, if you'll mail order from Europe. Just watch the duty fees. Even still, the prices are generally MUCH better.

[svelocity]

Just a quick update...
I'm going with the Shutter Precision hub and, based on a V-salon thread, I purchased it packaged with a light through Kerry at: http://www.klite.com.au/
The package price seems really good and I was very impressed with his help and patience in answering all my questions. The hub will be on its way to Echelon John for a build so I will relay some real world impressions in the near future...
Thanks for everyone's input and suggestions.

Looking forward to reading your impressions once you have it built up!

[cogclog]

I'd also be interested in a review. We sell a fair number I Schmidt hubs at my shop but aside from shimano I haven't seen many alternatives...

[saab2000]

Ditto the others. I'm also interested in a review of the light. I have read of stories of up to about 800 lumens but I'm skeptical. Still, kudos to the manufacturer for trying. Definitely interested in hearing about your experiences.

[flydhest]

So ... are these a good choice for a commuter? Overkill? The commute is only 2 miles but the thought of never needing batteries/charging is very appealing.

[kohlboto]

So ... are these a good choice for a commuter? Overkill? The commute is only 2 miles but the thought of never needing batteries/charging is very appealing.

exactly. That's why I'm trying this out.

[saab2000]

So ... are these a good choice for a commuter? Overkill? The commute is only 2 miles but the thought of never needing batteries/charging is very appealing.

Totally worth it if your commuter isn't a POS and you have a reasonably secure place to park it.

I have a single speed winter bike with a Shimano dynamo hub. No noticeable additional drag (it is measurable I am sure but you don't feel it on the bike) and the amount of light and focus of the beam is respectable, especially if you get a good light like Busch & Müller IQ CYO or Supernova E3 Pro or Schmidt Edelux.

Never charge a light again for your commuter. At least not the headlight. There are dynamo taillights too but they're a bit more complicated and likely not as nice as the best battery lights.

[davidj]

Go with the Schmidt SON. Mine is an older model 28 with over 35,000 trouble free km.. Great product.

[roydyates]

Go with the Schmidt SON. Mine is an older model 28 with over 35,000 trouble free km.. Great product.

+1
if you get the schmidt, you won't be pondering whether you ought to upgrade.